Skip to main content

Conversation about Richard Brody and the passing of Tobe Hooper and George A. Romero, at the NewYorker Movie Facebook Club

Kai Mihm
In 2017 two great and highly influential american genre directors passed away: Tobe Hooper and George A. Romero. Richard Brody didn't write a single sentence about them. Why do think he didn't care to honor them? (And how do you feel about their work?)
Top of Form
LikeShow more reactions

David Troia Filmmakers who specialize in Horror are almost always disrespected by critics. Sad but True.

Kai Mihm Not over here in Europe... (In Germany Romero's death was in every paper and even featured in the TV-news...)

rien Rourke
Brien Rourke He might have doubted that Romero was really dead.
en Eisner
Ken Eisner Perhaps it was only temporary.
rien Rourke
Brien Rourke "Everything is temporary!"

ark Schaffer
ichard Schilling
Richard Schilling You may want to use Google before you post, since he wrote even more than "a single sentence" about George A Romero in July 2017. I remembered reading it.
ai Mihm
Kai Mihm Could you post link? Because I am unable to find the article you talk about. Thanks a lot!
atrick McEvoy-Halston
Patrick McEvoy-Halston Expanded and transformed the genre of horror:

So here, just one sentence, but with that commentary, not quite a slight.Manage

“The Love Witch” transforms a wide range…
ai Mihm
Kai Mihm Yes, I saw that. Pretty meager, I think.
ai Mihm
Kai Mihm But that cannot be what Richard Schilling meant.
atrick McEvoy-Halston
Patrick McEvoy-Halston Kai Mihm But it is, I believe -- he references July 2017. To me, what is there really isn't sufficient to justify telling you to try googling first before... but, nevertheless, the fact that it is Romero's passing away and a remembrance of his significant virtues which prompts Brody's discussion of other directors, could certainly make for it sticking in the mind later on as a whole article collected all around Romero.

yan Spencer
Ryan Spencer Forty-plus years ago, one of cinema’s most anxiety-inducing spectacles was unleashed. It was a time of cynicism, violence, paranoia and the collapse of a working class that was being outsourced and made obsolete by technology. Casual, everyday sexism undermined women’s equality by systematic objectification and enabling of abusers. Industrialized slaughter of animals was destroying the environment. So, not all that different from today. Texas Chainsaw Massacre beautifully intertwines horror and politics. I recommend everyone here watch (or rewatch) it immediately.
atrick McEvoy-Halston
Patrick McEvoy-Halston Neat post, but elides the virtues of the rise of the professional class, who have the mental temperature to actually do something about all these things.

atrick McEvoy-Halston
Patrick McEvoy-Halston Kai Mihm Inspired by exceptional critics of his acquaintance, Richard Brody finds out what he's missing:

The modern history of the cinema (actually, the…
yan Spencer
Ryan Spencer I have a certain respect for the Resident Evil series, however I think the point of this article is to try to elucidate the idea that this particular film is made without irony or critique. I wouldn't agree with that, nor would I argue that to be the case with Hooper's Texas Chainsaw Massacre which is maybe your reason for posting it here? TCM is specifically about those well beneath the "professional class," but that doesn't mean it is explicitly for them or exclusive of others.
atrick McEvoy-Halston
Patrick McEvoy-Halston Ryan Spencer The reason is actually that I find the horror genre is becoming big amongst literate twenty-something year olds -- the men especially. Horror, sci-fi, fantasy, comics -- but all done with a literary edge. Someone like Brody, who doesn't seem to have any fear of keeping a distance from a genre to keep himself seeming professional, would seem a natural critic for some of these bright young minds to engage with. But there's a difference, in that the way you typify our culture seems a match to that characterized by Brody as Paul W.S. Anderson's, and which may be a match for those twenty-somethings making genre the seed from which all varieties of culture might bloom and which perhaps best reflects the base of the world we live in (horror?) more than "fiction" does, rather than an adjunct. 

Your, "Forty-plus years ago, one of cinema’s most anxiety-inducing spectacles was unleashed. It was a time of cynicism, violence, paranoia and the collapse of a working class that was being outsourced and made obsolete by technology. Casual, everyday sexism undermined women’s equality by systematic objectification and enabling of abusers. Industrialized slaughter of animals was destroying the environment. So, not all that different from today."

does not match up well with Brody's "At the same time, “Resident Evil” is a relentless reflection of the tawdriness of strip malls, of the dun grimness of heavy industry, of the sense of decisions being made by abstract higher-ups that make for a plant closing or a store being shuttered, of the daily threat of violence and the need to stay vigilant and look tough, of the sense of embattlement in a harrowingly desolate landscape, and of the escape into simulation and the vicarious as the only, and fleeting, feeling of heroism that the daily struggle—or the daily round of boredom—offers. The absurd fantasy that Anderson offers up plays like a documentary of an extreme state of mind—and turns it into a stereotype which, in being represented with such efficacy, propagates itself."

One's "reality," the other's an "extreme state of mind." I would guess he'd fear you might be "propagating itself," and so the reason why critics like Brody stay away from "Texas Chainsaw"? Whatever it's actual qualities, qualities they recognize and are drawn to want to salute, they recognize they're being drawn to embrace a source of film culture out of which has mostly come an attitude they're averse to and recognize as a threat.

Ryan Spencer I think I agree; you are correct, I do not share Brody's view as expressed in his piece on Resident Evil. I would also say that most horror is extreme in it's depiction; Romero's Night of The Living Dead is about post-war isolationism and fear of "the other" - same with It Comes at Night which was a very underrated film of 2017. I suppose a lot of young viewers and upcoming twenty-something story-tellers (from which I am 20ish years removed, so) have a much more democratic view of genre. However, I think it's women in horror who are doing the most interesting things in the past couple of years; Karyn Kusama's The Invitation, Julia Ducournau's Raw, Jennifer Kent’s The Babadook... (Ducournau cites TCM as a huge influence).
Bottom of Form


Popular posts from this blog

Old Youth

You write about how poverty breeds creativity. You think about how scavenging for wild food gives you the perfect opportunity to slow down, to really appreciate your surroundings. You talk about how frugality is more environmentally sustainable. You pontificate on why creating meals from scratch is cheaper, healthier and deeply satisfying. Then you run out of cooking oil.You love fat. As a child you ate margarine by the spoonful. You didn't know any better. Now you've moved on to more delicious pastures. As a cook you can never resist sneaking in that extra bit of butter, that tablespoonful of olive oil, that dab of bacon grease. You believe that cake is a vessel for frosting, that salad dressing should be two parts oil to one part vinegar, and that packaged low-fat foods are a symptom of the decline of Western civilization. Fat makes food taste good.Under the best of circumstances, you have eight or nine varieties of fat on hand. In ascending order of importance: chicken drip…

Superimposing another "fourth-wall" Deadpool

I'd like to superimpose the fourth-wall breaking Deadpool that I'd like to have seen in the movie. In my version, he'd break out of the action at some point to discuss with us the following:
1) He'd point out that all the trouble the movie goes to to ensure that the lead actress is never seen completely naked—no nipples shown—in this R-rated movie was done so that later when we suddenly see enough strippers' completely bared breasts that we feel that someone was making up for lost time, we feel that a special, strenuous effort has been made to keep her from a certain fate—one the R-rating would even seemed to have called for, necessitated, even, to properly feed the audience expecting something extra for the movie being more dependent on their ticket purchases. That is, protecting the lead actress was done to legitimize thinking of those left casually unprotected as different kinds of women—not as worthy, not as human.   

2) When Wade/Deadpool and Vanessa are excha…

True Detective cont'd

Recently, Rachel Syme wrote this
As the dust settles on the “True Detective” finale, and the adventures of Rust Cohle and Marty Hart fade into the television firmament like the distant stars they found so meaningful, at least one thing is clear: it didn’t quite end the way we wanted it to. There is no doubt that the writer, Nic Pizzolatto, and director, Cary Fukunaga, pulled off a midseason coup, giving us a show in the January doldrums that caused temporary mass insanity. Like one of Rust’s intoxicating philosophical koans about sentient meat, “True Detective” cast a kind of spell over its viewers, convincing them that no matter what it was they were watching it was at the very least something worth the hours of debating, clicking, parsing, and comment-section feuding. Moreover, the gorgeous cinematography depicting Louisiana in the gloaming, the delectable short-anthology format, and the movie-star bona fides made us believe that we were watching something novelistic, even approachi…