I mean, Gandalf talks so much shit to Wormtongue...
but it is almost precisely similar to Sarumon's shit-talking of him at the
finish of the novel, an action that lead to Wormtongue's smiting of him with a
sword, delivered, it is made to seem, righteously -- one is almost meant to
feel momentarily good for Worntongue, in that he refused to be further
degraded. Does Gandalf abjure total rejection of Gollum, Wormtongue and Saruman
because he, being a Tolkien representative, knows each one of them is going to endure
a period of being totally alone, of being naked, vulnerable, hounded, hated,
and friendless -- and thus a far worse fate than any of the Fellowship has to
endure, for none of them is ever THAT alone -- and that this fate is somehow
actually undeserved for their representing a "crime" that is in
everyone... that is in HIM?
What is Gollum? -- the most inquisitive and curious of
his kind, so the text explicitly states. What is Saruman? -- the most heedless
of established authority; the most modern. What is Wormtongue? -- an ambitious
intellect, who makes a grab at things that ought to be available to all, but
whom some proclaim -- the stupid and stodgy, that is -- absolute ownership of.
Tolkien was chastising part of himself, the part that wanted to grow outside of
constraints... and almost too much: verged on being conspicuous, drawing too
much attention as to why so much over-hate?... as if the "guilty"
party had to be punished to absolve the punisher any suspicious co-ownership of
the same motives/motivations.
There's a bit at the end of
the destruction of Sarumon's tower by the Ents, where Treebeard begins to
identify with Saruman, saying, "you know, if someone did the same to me --
destroyed all of my home -- I might try and hide out in a hole too," and
Gandalf replies, "No, you are not the least bit like him, for you would
never destroy --" and I thought, what's going on here is that Tolkien is
performing a kind of pseudo-empathy, pseudo-identification, through Treebeard,
so that he can convince himself that he tried that... he tried to get really
inside their head, when the truth is he has to keep some firm distance from
them else go down the hellish hole of merciless punishment -- handed out by
Middle Earth, if not by Gandalf -- they exist in the narrative to be destroyed
within.
Comments
Post a Comment